Reading and Taking Notes on Scholarly Articles

As we reach the end of the semester that means final papers and all the luggage that we must drag along with it. A annotated bibliography are one of the tools your professor will probably assign you before you begin drafting. This is a very important tool but also a very time consuming project. Depending upon how long your assigned paper is depends on how many annotations you will do. but before we get to all the good stuff on how to write and annotated bib, we must first learn how to read scholarly articles and take notes so we can compose a proper annotation.

I found a couple of outlets that may be helpful in completing the process.

From the pasadena.edu website.

How to Read and Take Notes on a Scholarly Journal Article

How to Understand the Author

The first thing you need to do in order to read and summarize a scholarly journal article is understand the author.  To understand the author, keep in mind the following:
  • Authors of journal articles always have an argument; they are trying to convince you of something
  • Authors can be both good and bad:
    • Good: authors present you with new, research-based information
    • Bad: authors can be biased and only present one side of the story
  • You are an author too!  Your thoughts and judgments about journal articles are worthwhile, so don't just take what other authors say on blind faith - question them!

How to Approach the Article

When you read journal articles, always remember that YOU are going to write a paper based on what you read.  So, do the following:
  • Keep in mind your research question (ex. "What is leadership in nursing?")
  • Focus on the information in the article that is relevant to your research question (skim over other parts)
  • Question everything you read - not everything is 100% true or correct
  • Think critically about what you read and try to build your own argument based on it

Steps to Read the Article

  1. Look at the structure of the article (most scientific articles follow the same specific format)
    1. Abstract (summary of the whole article)
    2. Introduction (why they did the research)
    3. Methodology (how they did the research)
    4. Results (what happened)
    5. Discussion (what the results mean)
    6. Conclusion (what they learned)
    7. References (whose research they read)
  2. Read the abstract and conclusion first (these have the main points)
  3. If you find anything in the abstract or conclusion that is important for your paper, search for the information
  4. If you need more information, then read through whole sections (usually discussion or results section)

How to Take Notes on the Article

There are a few major ways to take notes, but this is a personal style choice.  Try different ways, but use the one that fits you best.  Below are some suggestions for note-taking:
  • Pay attention to what each section is about.  The Abstract, Discussion, and Conclusion sections usually have the most important information.
  • Take notes while you are reading (that way you don't have to go back and re-read it when you write your paper)
  • Write summarizing notes for main points (in the margin, or on a separate piece of paper)
  • Highlight only very important quotes or terms

How to Reference the Article

There are two main ways to reference an article in your paper:
  • Quoting
    • Use quotations when the author’s original words are so special that you cannot reword it. 
    • Usually, use quotations for definitions.
    • A good rule of thumb: 1 quotation per page maximum.
  • Paraphrasing (Summarizing)
    • Use paraphrasing to tell your reader in your own words what the author had to say, in detail or in general terms.
    • This is most commonly used in academic writing.
    • A good rule of thumb: when writing a literature review, use 2-3 paraphrases per paragraph.
  • More Note Taking Tips 
  • even more Thomas Edison

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man ~ James Joyce

Image
I recently  picked  up Ulysses and felt like I probably should read  A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man before fully jumping into Ulysses. My experience with Joyce before this novel was his short story “The Dead” from his collection The Dubliners. I remember absolutely enjoying “The Dead,” but like most readers, who approach Ulysses for the first time,I felt a little overwhelmed. I am a big fan of stream-of-conscious narration. Virginia Woolf and William Faulkner are two of my favorite Modernist writers. Further, as a fan of serious literature, I need to conquer Joyce at somepoint (and prepare for my intense Faulkner course next semester).  So now, onto this fine piece of literary experimentation. Joyce’s   A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man  poses basic questions about the human condition. A coming-of-age story in its truest sense, Stephen Dedalus finds himself asking and pondering some life’s most trivial questions. These questions, however, were some of the most
Read more

Pragmatic Overtones in Cormac McCarthy’s The Orchard Keeper

Image
 I n Walter Sullivan’s 1965 review of Cormac McCarthy’s first novel The Orchard Keeper, Sullivan claims McCarthy’s novel takes shape in “the middle of the agrarian influence” (721). This quote sends up a flare within the McCarthy community of scholars, who continue to debate Sullivan’s claims. Sullivan also acknowledges that McCarthy can be read as an author who has “had enough sense to see in the land a source of human salvation. [McCarthy] is a kind of anachronism who celebrates the traditional values in the traditional way” (721). However, many recent scholars disagree with Sullivan’s claims about the “land as a source of human salvation.” In her book Reading the World: Cormac McCarthy’s Tennessee Period, Dianne Luce states that, “[i]t is a mistake either to confuse East Tennessee with the plantation South or to label McCarthy a latter-day Agrarian” (271). In making this comment, she also argues that The Orchard Keeper can be read “in the context of the classic Southern Agrar
Read more

Classics Club Book List

http://theclassicsclubblog.wordpress.com/ Here it is. Finally, My Classics Club Book List. There are several key titles missing, well that is because I have read those. I do plan to review each book and also back track and review the classics I have read. I would like to complete this list by December, 12, 2017 five years. I'm sure that many more will fall into this list. Achebe, Chinua: Things Fall Apart Anderson, Sherwood: Winesburg, Ohio Austen, Jane: Emma Austen, Jane: Pride and Prejudice Bellow, Saul: Herzog Bellow, Saul: The Adventures of Augie March Bellow, Saul: Henderson the Rain King Bellow, Saul: Seize the Day Bradbury, Ray: Fahrenheit 451 Bradbury, Ray: The Illustrated Man Bronte, Charlotte: Jane Eyre Browning, Elizabeth Barrett: Aurora Leigh Burke, Edmund: A Philosophical Enquiry Carroll, Lewis: Alice in Wonderland Cather, Willa: A Lost Lady Cather, Willa: My Antonia Cather, Willa: Death Comes for the Archbishop Cather, Willa: Lucy Gayheart
Read more