The Craft of Research: Chapter 7 "Making Good Arguements"
Every argument, research or not, is built out of the answers to five questions in that conversation, questions that you must ask yourself on your readers’ behalf: 1. What is my claim? 2. What reasons support my claim? 3. What evidence supports my reasons? 4. Do I acknowledge alternatives / complications / objections, and how do I respond? 5. What principle makes my reasons relevant to my claim? (We call this principle a warrant.) (Booth 109). A claim is a sentence that asserts something that may be true or false and so needs support: The world is warming up. The main claim of a report is the sentence (or more) that the whole report supports (some call this sentence your thesis). If you wrote a report to prove that the world is warming up, the sentence stating that would be your main claim. A reason is a sentence supporting a claim, main or not. The first kind of support, a reason, is a statement that gives your readers cause to accept your claim. W...